No 32

 

VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS

 

OF THE

 

HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY

 

____________

 

 

WEDNESDAY 26 MAY 1999

 

 

1       Meeting of House

         The House met pursuant to adjournment.  The Speaker (Hon J K G Oswald) took the Chair and                       read prayers.

 

2       Petition No 50

         The Clerk announced that the following Member had lodged a Petition for presentation:

 

50    Mr Venning, from 124 residents of South Australia, requesting that the House oppose the recommendation that the Kapunda Harness Racing Club cease to function as a trotting club.

 

3               Legislative Review Committee – Reports – Thirteenth Report and Unproclaimed Legislation

Mr Condous brought up the Thirteenth Report 1998/99 of the Committee.

Report received.

 

Mr Condous brought up the Report of the Committee on Unproclaimed Legislation.

Report received.

 

4       Questions

         Questions without notice were asked.

 

5       Grievance debate

         The Speaker proposed - That the House note grievances.

         Debate ensued.

         Question put and passed.

 

6       Public Works Committee - Report – Southern Expressway – Stage 2 - Motion to note 

Mr Lewis, pursuant to notice, moved - That the Ninety-First Report of the Committee on the Southern Expressway – Stage 2 be noted.

         Debate ensued.

         Question put and passed.


 

7       Public Works Committee - Report – Botanic, Wine and Rose Development – Stage 2 - Motion to note 

Mr Lewis, pursuant to notice, moved - That the Ninety-Second Report of the Public Works Committee on the Botanic, Wine and Rose Development – Stage 2 be noted.

         Ordered, on motion of Ms Thompson, that the debate be adjourned until Wednesday 2 June.

 

8       Public Works Committee - Report – Adelaide Festival Centre Upgrade – Stage 2 – Asbestos Management/Removal – Air Conditioning - Motion to note 

Mr Lewis, pursuant to notice, moved - That the Ninety-Third Report of the Public Works Committee on the Adelaide Festival Centre Upgrade – Stage 2 – Asbestos Management/Removal  – Air Conditioning, be noted.

         Debate ensued.

____________

 

The time for the consideration of Standing Committee Reports having expired, the debate was adjourned (Ms Thompson, by leave) and made an Order of the Day for Wednesday 2 June.

____________

 

      9 Suspension of Standing Orders – Appropriation Bill

The Minister for Education, Children’s Services and Training (Hon M R Buckby), pursuant to notice, moved – That on Thursday 27 May 1999 Standing Orders be so far suspended as to enable –

     (a)   the Premier to have leave to continue his remarks on the Appropriation Bill immediately after moving “That this Bill be now read a second time”;

              (b)   the Treasurer (Hon R I Lucas) to be immediately admitted to the House for the purpose of giving a speech in relation to the Appropriation Bill; and

              (c)   the second reading speech on the Appropriation Bill to be resumed on motion.

         Debate ensued.

         Question put and passed.

 

10      Appropriation Bill  – Motion for attendance of Treasurer

The Minister for Education, Children’s Services and Training, pursuant to notice, moved – That a Message be sent to the Legislative Council requesting that the Treasurer be permitted to attend at the Table of the House on Thursday 27 May 1999 for the purpose of giving a speech in relation to the Appropriation Bill.

         Question put and passed.

 

11      Offshore Minerals Bill

The Minister for Education, Children’s Services and Training, pursuant to notice, moved – That he have leave to introduce a Bill for an Act relating to exploration for, and the recovery of, minerals (other than petroleum) in the first three nautical miles of the territorial sea in respect of South Australia; and for related purposes.

Question put and passed.

 

Bill presented and read a first time.

The Minister moved – That this Bill be now read a second time.

Ordered, on the motion of Ms Hurley, that the debate be adjourned until tomorrow


 

12      Statutes Amendment (Financial Institutions) Bill

The Minister for Education, Children’s Services and Training, pursuant to notice, moved – That he have leave to introduce a Bill for an Act to amend the Debits Tax Act 1994, the Financial Institutions Duty Act 1983 and the Stamp Duties Act 1923.

Question put and passed.

 

Bill presented and read a first time.

The Minister moved – That this Bill be now read a second time.

Ordered, on the motion of Ms Hurley, that the debate be adjourned until tomorrow

 

13      Message from the Legislative Council

  The following Message from the Legislative Council was received and read:

 

  Listening Devices (Miscellaneous) Amendment Bill                               Message No 54

MR SPEAKER - The Legislative Council has disagreed to the amendments made by the House of Assembly in the Listening Devices (Miscellaneous) Amendment Bill, for the Reason indicated in the annexed Schedule. The Legislative Council returns the Bill herewith and desires its reconsideration.

         Legislative Council, 25 May 1999                                                    J C Irwin, PRESIDENT

 

Schedule of the amendments made by the House of Assembly

and disagreed to by the Legislative Council

 

No 1                         Clause 7, page 4, line 6—Leave out "sections are substituted" and substitute:

 

                                  section is substituted

 

No 2                         Clause 7, page 4, line 21 to page 6, line 22 (inclusive)—Leave out proposed new sections 5A to 5G (inclusive).

 

No 3                                            Clause 8, page 7, lines 5 to 11—Leave out proposed subsection (4a).

 

No 4                                            Clause 8, page 7, lines 15 and 16—Leave out proposed paragraph (a) and insert:

 

                 (a)           if the warrant is for the use of a listening device, the extent to which the privacy of a person would be likely to be interfered with by use of the listening device; and

 

No 5                                            Clause 9, page 9, lines 19 to 21—Leave out proposed paragraph (h).

 

No 6                                            Clause 9, page 10, lines 7 to 11—Leave out proposed paragraph (h) and insert:

 

                  (h)           the applicant must, as soon as practicable after the issue of the warrant, forward to the judge an affidavit verifying the facts referred to in paragraph (c) and a copy of the duplicate warrant.

 

No 7                                            Clause 10, page 13, line 26—Leave out "following paragraphs" and insert:

 

                  following paragraph

 

No 8                                            Clause 10, page 13, lines 33 and 34—Leave out proposed paragraph (d).

 

No 9         Clause 11, page 14, lines 5 to 10—Leave out proposed subsection (1).

 

No 10      Clause 13, page 17, line 13 to page 18, line 2 (inclusive)—Leave out this clause and substitute:

 

                                  Amendment of s. 8—Possession, etc., of declared listening device

                  13. Section 8 of the principal Act is amended by striking out the penalty provision at the foot of subsection (2) and substituting the following penalty provision:

 

                             Maximum penalty: $10 000 or imprisonment for 2 years.

 

No 11      Clause 14, page 18, lines 13 and 14—Leave out "or tracking".

 

No 12      Clause 15, page 19, lines 20 and 21—Leave out proposed paragraph (c).

 

No 13      Schedule, page 20, after line 11—Insert the following statute law revision amendments:

 

                      Section 8(1)                                     Strike out "shall apply" and substitute "applies".

 

                 Section 8(2)                                     Strike out "shall" and substitute "must".

                                                                          Strike out "hereby".

                                                                          Insert "or her" after "his".

 

                 Section 8(3)                                     Strike out "of this section".

 

                 Section 8(4)                                     Strike out "upon" and substitute ""on".

                                                                          Strike out "shall" and substitute "will".

 

                 Section 8(5)                                     Strike out "shall be deemed" and substitute "will be taken".

 

                 Section 8(6)                                     Strike out "Chief Executive Officer as defined in the Government Management and Employment Act 1985" and substitute "Chief Executive as defined in the Public Sector Management Act 1995".

 

Schedule of the Reasons of the Legislative Council for disagreeing with the foregoing amendments

 

Because it is believed that the amendments do not improve the Bill.

 

                                                            J M Davis CLERK OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

 

14      Postponement of business

Ordered - That Order of the Day: Government Business No 1 be postponed and taken into consideration after Order of the Day: Government Business No 2.


 

15      Explosives (Broad Creek) Amendment Bill

Order of the Day read for the adjourned debate on the question - That this Bill be now read a second time.

Debate resumed.

         Question put and passed.

 

         Bill read a second time.

         Proceeded, by leave, to the third reading.

 

         Bill read a third time and passed.

 

16      Industrial and Employee Relations (Workplace Relations) Amendment Bill

         Order of the Day read for the further consideration in Committee of this Bill.

 

In Committee

                                                Clause No 4 further considered and agreed to.

                                                Clauses Nos 5 to 28 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 29 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 1):

 


                       Ayes, 22

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 18

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Hon M D Rann

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clauses Nos 30 to 40 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 41 amended and agreed to.


                                                Clause No 42 amended

Question – That the clause as amended be agreed to – put.

Committee divided (No 2):

 


                       Ayes, 23

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 19

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clause No 43 amended and agreed to.

                                                Clause No 44 agreed to.


                                       Clause No 45 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 3):

 


                       Ayes, 23

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 19

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clauses Nos 46 and 47 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 48 amended and agreed to.

                                                Clause No 49 agreed to.


                                                Clause No 50 read

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 4):

 


                       Ayes, 22

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 20

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Mr McEwen

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clause No 51 read

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 5):

 


                       Ayes, 23

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 19

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clauses Nos 52 and 53 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 54 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 6):

 


                       Ayes, 23

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon R L Brokenshire

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 19

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Ms Ciccarello

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clause No 55 read.

 

         To report progress and ask leave to sit again.

 

____________

 

         The House having resumed:

Hon D C Wotton reported that the Committee had considered the Bill referred to it, had made progress therein and asked leave to sit again.

Ordered - That the Committee have leave to sit again on motion.

 

17      Extension of time for adjournment

The Minister for Government Enterprises (Hon M H Armitage) moved - That the time for moving the adjournment of the House be extended beyond 10.00 pm.

 

         Speaker’s Ruling – Disagreement to

On a point of order being raised, that the motion was moved after 10.00 pm, the Speaker ruled that the motion could be moved after 10.00 pm, if at 10.00 pm a division was in progress.

 

Mr Clarke moved – That the ruling of the Speaker be disagreed with.

Motion, by leave, withdrawn.

 

Question - That the time for moving the adjournment of the House be extended beyond 10.00 pm – put and passed.


 

18      Industrial and Employee Relations (Workplace Relations) Amendment Bill

         Ordered – That further consideration in Committee of this Bill be now resumed.

 

In Committee

                                    Clause No 55 further considered and agreed to.

                                    Clauses Nos 56 and 57 agreed to.

                                    Clause No 58 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 7):

 


                       Ayes, 22

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 18

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

                                                Clause No 59 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 60 amended and agreed to.

                                                Clauses Nos 61and 62 agreed to.


                                                Clause No 63 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 8):

 


                       Ayes, 22

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Ms Maywald

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 18

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Mr Hill

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clause No 64 read.

 

         To report progress and ask leave to sit again.

 

____________

 

         The House having resumed:

Hon D C Wotton reported that the Committee had considered the Bill referred to it, had made progress therein and asked leave to sit again.

Ordered - That the Committee have leave to sit again on motion.

 

19      Suspension of Standing Orders

Minister for Government Enterprises, without notice, moved - That Standing Orders be so far suspended as to enable the House to sit beyond midnight.

Question put and passed, without a negative voice, there being an absolute majority of the whole number of Members of the House.

 

20      Industrial and Employee Relations (Workplace Relations) Amendment Bill

         Ordered - That the further consideration in Committee of this Bill be now resumed.

 

In Committee

                                                Clause No 64 further considered and agreed to.


 

____________

 

It being Midnight

THURSDAY 27 MAY 1999

____________

 

                                                Clause No 65 amended and agreed to.

                                                Clauses Nos 66 to 72 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 73 amended.

Question – That the clause as amended be agreed to – put.

Committee divided (No 9):

 


                       Ayes, 21

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 17

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clause No 74 agreed to.

                                                Clause No 75 amended and agreed to.

                                                Clauses Nos 76 to 95 agreed to.


                                                Clause No 96 read.

Question – That the clause stand as published – put.

Committee divided (No 10):

 


                       Ayes, 21

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Hon J K G Oswald

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 17

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

                                                Clauses Nos 97 and 98 agreed to.

                                                Title agreed to.

 

____________

 

         The House having resumed:

Hon D C Wotton reported that the Committee had considered the Bill referred to it and had agreed to the same with amendments.


 

The Minister for Government Enterprises moved - That this Bill be now read a third time.

Question put.

House divided (No. 11):

 


                       Ayes, 21

 

Hon M K Brindal

Hon D C Brown

Hon M R Buckby

Mr Condous

Hon I F Evans

Hon G M Gunn

Mr Hamilton-Smith

Hon G A Ingerson

Hon R G Kerin

Hon D C Kotz

Mr Lewis

Hon W A Matthew

Mr McEwen

Mr Meier

Mrs Penfold

Mr Scalzi

Hon R B Such

Mr Venning

Mr Williams

Hon D C Wotton

Hon M H Armitage (Teller)


        Noes, 17

 

Mr Atkinson

Ms Bedford

Ms Breuer

Mr Clarke

Mr Conlon

Mr Foley

Mrs Geraghty

Mr Hanna

Ms Hurley

Mr Koutsantonis

Ms Rankine

Mr Snelling

Ms Stevens

Ms Thompson

Ms White

Mr Wright

Ms Key (Teller)


 

         So it was resolved in the affirmative.

 

         Bill read a third time and passed.

 

21      Message from the Legislative Council

         The following Message from the Legislative Council was received and read:

 

         Attendance of the Treasurer                                                                   Message No 55

MR SPEAKER - The Legislative Council has granted leave to the Treasurer (The Hon R I Lucas) to attend the House of Assembly on Thursday, 27 May 1999, for the purpose of giving a speech in relation to the Appropriation Bill if he thinks fit.

         Legislative Council, 26 May 1999                                                    J C Irwin, PRESIDENT

 

22      Adjournment

         House adjourned at 1.03 am until today at 10.30 am.

 

 

____________

 


 

MOTION OF WHICH NOTICE WAS GIVEN

 

 

         For Thursday 27 May 1999

Notice of Motion Private Member’s Bills/Committees/Regulations –

 

Mr Conlon to move – That this House establish a Select Committee to examine the amount of funds to be raised by the proposed Emergency Services Levy, the method by which they will be raised and the purposes to which those funds will be applied.

 

____________

 

 

         Present during the day - All Members except Mr De Laine and Hon J L Hall.

 

         The following Pairs were handed in at the Table during the days proceedings:

 

         Division No 1 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon R G Kerin, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr Clarke, Mr De Laine, Mr Hill

 

         Division No 2 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 3 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 4 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 5 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 6 -

               Ayes - Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 7 -

               Ayes - Hon R L Brokenshire, Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Ms Ciccarello, Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 8 -

               Ayes - Hon R L Brokenshire, Hon J L Hall, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Ms Ciccarello, Mr De Laine, Hon M D Rann.


 

         Division No 9 -

               Ayes - Hon R L Brokenshire, Hon J L Hall, Ms Maywald, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Ms Ciccarello, Mr De Laine, Mr Hill, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 10 -

               Ayes - Hon R L Brokenshire, Hon J L Hall, Ms Maywald, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Ms Ciccarello, Mr De Laine, Mr Hill, Hon M D Rann.

 

         Division No 11 -

               Ayes - Hon R L Brokenshire, Hon J L Hall, Ms Maywald, Hon J W Olsen.

               Noes - Ms Ciccarello, Mr De Laine, Mr Hill, Hon M D Rann.

 

 

 

                                                                                                            J K G Oswald

                                                                                                            SPEAKER

 

G D Mitchell

CLERK OF THE HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY